The Supreme Court has strongly criticized the Uttar Pradesh government for its “high-handed” approach to demolishing homes in Prayagraj, stating that the actions had “shocked its conscience.”
A bench comprising Justices Abhay S Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan expressed disapproval over how residences were bulldozed within 24 hours of serving notices, leaving homeowners without adequate time to appeal.
“It is deeply concerning how residential properties were demolished in such an arbitrary and forceful manner. The entire process is alarming, and courts cannot permit such actions. If we allow this once, it will set a dangerous precedent,” the bench remarked.
The court ruled that the demolished houses could be reconstructed at the expense of the petitioners, provided they submit an undertaking to file appeals before the appellate authority within the given timeframe. However, the petitioners must not assert ownership rights over the land or create third-party interests.
If their appeals are rejected, they will be required to demolish the structures at their own cost. The court adjourned the matter to allow the petitioners time to submit the necessary undertakings.
Defending the state’s actions, Attorney General R. Venkataramani assured the court that due process was followed while issuing the notices. He also highlighted the challenge of managing widespread illegal encroachments, which the state government has been striving to control.
Previously, the Supreme Court had censured the Uttar Pradesh government for razing homes in Prayagraj without adhering to legal procedures, warning that such actions send a “shocking and dangerous message.”
